WIP Your Product into Shape

What is WIP?

Enjoy-Drink-Cozy-Cappuccino-Cup-Coffee-Cream-703146WIP simply means work in process (also sometimes, Work In Progress). This metric simply measures how many items (features, stories, backlog items, tasks) your team have started to develop, but have yet to complete. In other words, how many items are currently being developed. This simple metric is extremely important, and a useful number to track and control. In this post we will discuss the reasons for limiting your WIP, how to do so, and how to track your work in process using VSTS.

You’re Doing Too Much

overloadImagine the following scenario: You are walking down Main street, carrying a box. Not a problem. The box is small enough that you can easily pick it up and carry it from wherever it was that you got it to wherever you are going. All is fine.

Now imagine, that you are carrying two boxes. Still not a problem. Granted, carrying one box would be easier, but you believe that the discomfort of carrying two boxes is preferable to the discomfort of having to make the trip twice. You can do it.

Now imagine that you are trying to pick up and carry three boxes. Not easy at all, and the weight, strain, and bulkiness of the trio makes you reconsider the wisdom of trying to take so much with you at once. Staggering carefully might end up taking longer than a second trip would…

Now imagine that you are trying to pick up and carry four boxes. Blind, because you cannot see around all of the boxes, you bump into someone else carrying a box, and you both fall, the contents of your boxes spilling, some shattering.

You really should have limited how many boxes you carry at once…

Setting WIP Limits

What is a WIP Limit?

stop-limit-reachedWIP limits are exactly what they sound like – you limit the number of items that you will work on concurrently, not taking on any new work, until the number of items you are developing is less than the limit. In our above story, the poor courier should have set his limit to 3, possibly even 2 in order for his work to flow optimally, or for him to be effective. The courier could easily carry one item, and could increase his throughput when he carried two items, but slowed down when he was carrying three, and literally crashed when trying to manage four. Note that this is purely individual – another courier could possibly manage three or four boxes.

I hope the metaphor is obvious. The courier is you and your development team. Boxes are your backlog items – whatever you’re tracking (stories, features, tasks, etc.). Some teams can work on one item in collaboration, others no more than two. A third team might prefer to work on twice as many tasks as they have members. It is individual, and it depends on the team, the individuals, and of course, the nature of their work.

But how do you know what limit to set?

Picking a WIP Limit

NO-SILVER-BULLET-HEADER-1080x675Here’s the simple truth: there are no silver bullets. No one can tell your team what the ideal WIP limit is. You should start with whatever makes sense to your team. Change that number to whatever makes sense to you. Change it when circumstances change. Change it to experiment.

If your team tends to collaborate frequently, start with a low number – three, because why not three… If your team rarely collaborates, start with a higher number, tied to the number of developers you have on your team, e.g. 1 or 2 per team member, plus/minus 1.

Next, start tracking metrics that are important to your team. A few examples are:

  • Throughput – the number of items processed (developed) in a given period of time (day, week, sprint – whichever, just be consistent). You want this number to be high
  • Defect Rate – the number of bugs/defects found (in QA, UAT, production, etc.) in a given period of time. You want this number to be low
  • Deployment Frequency, and deployment time. You want these numbers to be high and low, respectively
  • Lead Time – the amount of time that passes between requesting a change to the system and its delivery to the system’s users. You want this number to be low

At a regular cadence, for example, every sprint retrospective, evaluate the numbers. Experiment with lowering your WIP limit. After a period of time, look at your metrics. Did they improve? If so, great! Keep on doing what you’re doing. If not, either adjust (increase) your WIP limit or adjust your practices so that you perform better at the lower limit. Measure again. Rinse and repeat.

Tracking WIP Limits in VSTS

Tracking Your WIP Limit in Your Kanban Board

Limiting your WIP is a practice that should be mostly autonomous, that is to say, at the team’s discretion. As such, you need to set it and visualize it where the team visualizes their work. If you go to VSTS’s boards, you will notice two numbers beside the name of each column (except for the ‘New’ and ‘Done’ columns). The first number represents the number of items in the column, the second represents the WIP limit. In the following board, the ‘Approved’ column has a WIP limit of 5, meaning that the team must approve (or refine) a work item before they can consider a sixth item. This team’s ‘Committed’ WIP limit is set to 6, meaning that they can work on no more than 6 concurrent work items, as a whole team.

image

If the team takes on a 6th item to be approved, VSTS won’t block them, but the number will turn red to note that the team is doing something wrong:

image

Tracking Your WIP Limit in the VSTS Team Dashboard

The VSTS boards put this information in the team members’ faces, enough to be noticed, but not so much as to get in the way of progress. This may be enough for the team. Some teams may want more. Some teams may want to have this displayed on the team’s dashboard, where it might be visible to anybody, or always visible. Perhaps the Scrum Master or the team leader may want to know what is going on. Perhaps they want to show the dashboard to middle management in order to prove that reducing WIP is important.

One thing you might do is add a Work Item Query that tracks the work items in a given column (add a where clause like Board Column =  Committed), and add a Query Tile to your dashboard that counts the number of items returned by the query.

image

You can even set the tile with conditional formatting that would, for example, color the tile green if the count is less than the WIP limit, yellow if it’s at the limit, or red if it is above:

image

The end result is a query tile that really sticks out and lets whoever needs to know how well you are limiting your WIP:

image

Conclusion

In this blog post, we’ve discussed what WIP limit is, how to set it, and how to track it in VSTS. In the next post, we will discuss why reducing the WIP limit is so important, and how to incorporate WIP limit management into your real, day-to-day, corporate life.

Stay lean,

Assaf

About Assaf Stone

My name is Assaf Stone. I'm a senior ALM consultant in Microsoft's Premier Support for Developers Team. When not being kept busy by work, my wife, or my four kids, I like to practice archery, read books, and listen to 70's and 80's rock music. I would also like to just relax, if I had any more spare time!
This entry was posted in Agile, Productivity, Scrum, Self Management, Team, Uncategorized, VSTS and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.